Real Estate Recovery Is Only a Mirage

As the Great Recession drags on, albeit without official sanction, each and every silver cloud of economic news continues to harbor a dark lining. Most recently, amidst the mainstream media’s hubris over a supposedly stabilizing housing market, we read yesterday in the Denver Post that the region is bracing for yet another painful round of foreclosures. “Despite reports of a thawing housing market,” the paper noted in a front-page article, “yet another wave of foreclosure appears to be looming.” The fact that lenders are gearing up for this is apparent in the sharp spike in deed-of-trust assignments in Colorado. Compared to 2011, they’ve more than doubled in the first five months of this year.  Deeds of trust convey ownership rights of mortgages and the ability to foreclose on them, and they are therefore a reliable indicator of foreclosure activity to come.  According to the Post, if only half of the filings become actual foreclosure cases, foreclosures could spike to 2007’s crisis levels.

We have long predicted that home prices would eventually fall by at least 70% as debt deflation ran its course globally. This would imply that, despite the unprecedented drop in residential real estate values since 2007, residential values in the U.S. are only halfway to a bottom. Meanwhile, spotty signs of recovery in the housing market have caused the news media to hallucinate about the return of  good times, In Las Vegas, for one, home prices have fallen to levels so low that even real-estate pessimists would have to concede that there are great bargains to be had:  three-bedroom homes with swimming pools for $100,000, according to a friend of ours who lives in such a home herself. She paid $325,000 for it, though, and although Nevada’s underpriced housing will be a long-term plus for the local economy, it is unlikely to reverse the equity loss suffered by my friend, nor her despondence over having lost so large a piece of her retirement nest egg to debt deflation.

Gusher of Latino Cash

Miami real estate is recovering as well due to a gusher of hot money from Latin America. The city is probably better positioned than Las Vegas to benefit from this infusion over the long-term, but condo prices are approaching frothy levels that could create another bust. And in New York City, where Russian tycoons will not be outbid for penthouses, the $100 million apartment seems likely to become yesterday’s news before the inevitable bust arrives. Meanwhile, Denver’s real estate market never got overheated to begin with, since the city’s recovery from the oil-patch bust of the late 1980s was gradual.  For medium-to-large U.S. cities, the sluggish state of Denver’s economy probably falls near the middle of the boom-bust spectrum, somewhere between the Rust Belt  and New York/Boston.

And that is why a wave of foreclosures here would be bad news for other cities whose economies have been merely muddling along. Despite this, the mainstream media have taken an activist role in promoting the illusion of a housing recovery. A front-page story in the Wall Street Journal yesterday offered statistics from Zillow to support a picture of spotty recovery in real estate prices across the U.S. But guess which city was near the top of the list, with home values rising over the previous three months in more than 90% of zip code neighborhoods?  Answer: Denver. Considering what was being reported in the Denver Post on the same day (see above), we should take the Wall Street Journal’s good news with a grain of salt. As Denver goes, so goes the nation? It’s a possibility worth considering as the mainstream media continues to obsess over a recovery that isn’t — and never was.

***

(If you’d like to have Rick’s Picks commentary delivered free each day to your e-mail box, click here.)

  • Jason June 28, 2012, 6:09 am

    Although it’s too early to rejoice that the housing market crisis is over, there’s also a lot of good news. Home prices are starting to go back up, there are more contracts for new homes, including in the Denver area, and inventory is starting to drop, and not because banks are artificially trying to make it so like the last couple of years. At some point foreclosures have to slow down because so many people have already foreclosed so even if another round is coming, it couldn’t possibly be as high as it already has been.

  • Homes For Sale Mt Pleasant SC June 25, 2012, 4:34 am

    Thank you very much for your ideas to post comments. The content was really very interesting. I am really thankful to you for providing this unique information. Please keep sharing more and more information….

  • Rich June 21, 2012, 9:58 pm

    Just closed QQQ Jun 65 puts at profit.
    Bot some SPY 133 calls…

    • gary leibowitz June 21, 2012, 10:15 pm

      VLAD has a target similar to Goldma Sachs of 1285 on SPX.

  • redwilldanaher June 21, 2012, 9:01 pm

    Be sure to keep those infamous “blinders” on Gary. That blinders line might be your top one of the year.

  • John Jay June 21, 2012, 8:11 pm

    Any bets as to how close we get to the January 2013 deadline for the giant budget cuts before they all get repealed? The Republicans are pressured by the MIC, and the Democrats are pressured by the other lobbyists over this. I say the cuts never happen, just more kick the can.

  • gary leibowitz June 21, 2012, 7:52 pm

    A stock market crash along with Gold?

    I thought gold was the great equalizer.

    I even think FB has a shot at making good on its promise. Now that is way way out there. Read an article on how web 3.0, going mobile, will drive profits and advertisers in. I do love to hate this stock but I wouldn’t bet against them just yet.

  • Mark Uzick June 21, 2012, 5:59 pm

    Mario, have you heard that the Chinese have out-bid everyone and have bought the London Metals Exchange (LME)? The Hong Kong Exchage paid an astounding 180 times trailing net income for this Crown Jewel of London finance that has dominated the metals markets for 135 years!

    It’s an indication of their determination to unload their worthless FRN’s by stocking away industrial and precious metals that will have some real future value.

  • gary leibowitz June 21, 2012, 4:41 pm

    While the sales of homes have been sluggish, it is not breaking down. The other positive is that home prices have been going up these last 2 months, and the trend has been improving for over 1 year now.

    Not a great housing report but given time it will only be a positive for the economy from here. I only question if we have enough time. Current very low mortgage rates, lower commodity prices, and a stabilization overseas ssems to show the consumer comfort index is also showing signs of life.

    While AAPL is being scrutinized Gold takes a whipping. Was there a play on Gold to capture the drop?

    • Rick Ackerman June 21, 2012, 5:38 pm

      Yes, Gary, there was a “play.” As a lurker you would not have been privy to my forecast, but here is the tout for August Gold that I sent out Wednesday night when it was trading for around $1607:

      GCQ12 – August Gold (Last:1607.00) June 21, 2012 12:01 am GMT Yesterday’s histrionics created a bearish impulse leg on the hourly chart that was unnegated by the end-of-day rally. Nevertheless, the point ‘C’ low associated with an aging bullish target at 1653.30 remains intact, giving us a reason in theory to think the futures capable of rallying to that target within the next several days. And it had better happen that soon, since the bull cycle is getting heavier with each passing day. Even more immediately — and perhaps more realistically — the downtrend in motion late Wednesday night promised to deliver 1578.70 now that its p sibling at 1600.60 has been exceeded by a decisive $2.50. _______ UPDATE (10:15 a.m. EDT): The futures have plummeted $37 today, making a so-far low at 1578.60 — a dime from my target. The bounce thereupon has carried thus far to 1587.20.

    • gary leibowitz June 21, 2012, 5:46 pm

      Yes I wish I had played that move. I used to bet the futures and got gun shy with all commodities. I loved the thrill of naked bets until I got smacked with one.

      Learnt my lesson well. I still see stocks and commodities correcting together, and recovering together. I don’t see a break in SPX below the recent lows. If wrong than I missed another opportunity. I am still out the market but will probably re-enter soon if the drop stays in my parameters.

  • Mark Uzick June 21, 2012, 5:10 am

    Metropolitan areas that didn’t participate in the real estate bubble also didn’t participate in the “smart growth” fad.

    While various ingredients went into the making of the bubble and the financial crash that resulted when it popped, we can thank these moron “urban planners” for bringing this country and Europe to their financial knees.

    If you want to buy into the next real estate bubble ahead of the crowd, then find a metropolitan area that has instituted perimeters for growth that haven’t yet been filled but are nearly so. When home building starts to show a sustained recovery, this metro area will quickly fill up and become one of the bubbles; and anyone who bought as much as he could, using mostly borrowed money will quickly become very wealthy, but he had better liquidate before the bubble pops .

    • mario cavolo June 21, 2012, 6:34 am

      Hi Mark, similar to the point often cited here in China as to follow the big / govt urban/infrastructure planning money…. “If you want to buy an apt, find out where the govt has made project commitments on development, infrastructure, subway lines, roads, business tech zones, etc.” , buy there cheap and wait it out… Exactly what my wife did in her home town Shenyang, bought in the new south river area where first was the Olympics sport stadium built for the soccer matches, then govt since started adding a new development zone, private investment in the new mall, Walmart, etc. in the area, finally a year later the new subway opened up 5 minute’s walk…

      Cheers, Mario

    • Mark Uzick June 21, 2012, 8:45 am

      Hi Mario, your example is similar to the way development used to happen here: State entities would subsidize the expansion of development, creating an unnatural urban and suburban sprawl by building roads, highways and mass transit. From their plans you could predict where development was spreading to – purchase real estate and then wait for the area to be developed.

      What’s going on with “smart growth” is just the opposite: After creating sprawl and destroying the inner cities with their clumsy and corrupt interference in the market, the idiot planners are now repenting (But they never repent from being destructive busybodies, allowing development to happen in an organic, free market, fashion.) by trying to force everyone to live in high density tenements like our grandparents did. To do this they have put the areas surrounding cities off limits to development, thereby causing land prices to skyrocket during periods of growth, making it profitable to tear down single family homes and build high density housing. They also utilize various methods of obstructing traffic and reducing available parking, creating massive, time wasting and polluting traffic snarls in the futile belief that people will give up their cars and use mass transit.

      If you identify a city that has “smart growth” policies but hasn’t yet had a real estate bubble because they haven’t yet run out of room but is almost at that point, the next spurt of housing demand can make the speculator with some foresight rich.

  • Other Paul June 21, 2012, 5:09 am

    What/Who stops the Fed from “key-stroking” all the cash the US Government needs to continue funding extended unemployment, fill-in-the-blank debt/mortgage forgiveness (in Denver, too), green-energy projects, SS, Medicare/aid, food stamps, etc.?

    Who would have thought that we could have a $1.4T deficit and 10 yr Treasuries below 2%?

    I don’t see why the US’s Debt-to-GDP can’t be greater than Japan’s. What difference does it make if the funding comes from US, international (China), or “key-stroke” sources?

    OK, so the dollar’s purchasing power erodes. What’s new about that situation?

    • Mark Uzick June 21, 2012, 5:46 am

      Other Paul, theoretically, in a fiat system they could eliminate all direct taxation and fund the state by means of the inflation tax by simply printing as much money as they need to operate. This would eliminate layers of some of the most evil and abusive bureaucracy; and it would remove the economic distortions caused by an irrational tax code – it would bring about a huge economic boom as investment and business success would no longer be punished and a lot of hidden money would come out of hiding to be deployed in productive enterprise.

      But this scheme would only work if “government” spending was kept to 18% of GDP or, preferably, less. It has been show that modern economies cannot sustain spending levels greater than 18% of GDP for extended periods of time without suffering decline, which, in this case, would manifest as severe inflation, exacerbated by economic strangulation as an out of control expansion of the state took control over an ever increasing portion of economic activity.

    • Carol June 21, 2012, 3:50 pm

      Mark,

      ok course the scheme of inflation would work to fund government. The ONLY reason it is not used is because even though taxes are not needed they are used to control the population and to get the population to give up all their personal information to a central database (irs).

    • Mark Uzick June 21, 2012, 5:49 pm

      Carol, that’s my point: money printing is already being used as a partial way to fund the state; making it the sole means would eliminate much of the state’s power over us. It would be a partial reform, but, of course the statists would reject it on moral principles prescribed by their religion of the state, so both practical as well as natural rights arguments wouldn’t change their opposition to that idea.

      The idea of printing money is seductive enough that the more practical minded statists and moderates might go along with it. If it was combined with the legalization of competing free market money, it could be the path to an ever shrinking state as this competition pressured the state into printing and, therefore, spending as little as possible or otherwise finding that its money would buy much less anyway, causing real spending to shrink in either case.

  • John Jay June 21, 2012, 5:01 am

    I think at this time Freddie/Fannie/FHA are doing the bulk of the financing in the US mortgage market.
    FHA 3.5% down mortgages are crowding everyone else out of the picture I believe. Starting in 2013 millions of upside down HELOCs reset from interest only to fully amortizing mortgages. Plenty of those to hit the fan in the next five years or so. Here are some bullet points from a mortgage website:

    USDA 102% PURCHASE!!!

    FREDDIE MAC 125% RELIEF REFINANCE!!!

    I did not know the USDA is in the mortgage business too! And 125% from Freddie Mac? Such a deal!
    So after the great housing bubble experience, it is comforting to know that the US Government mortgage makers have learned nothing, and forgotten nothing!
    ZIRP is like that “temporary” income tax with holding that started in WWII, I believe. No need for those Fireside Chats with Uncle Ben, we all know the score by now.

  • Rich June 21, 2012, 2:27 am

    Sorry the Fed links were chopped and did not work.

    Meanwhile, TYX targeting 1.7% from 2.724%
    and TNX targeting 0.5% from 1.642%.

    Both are depression signatures…

    • Bradley June 21, 2012, 5:00 pm

      Might try using tinyurl’s next time.
      tinyurl.com

  • Rich June 21, 2012, 1:12 am

    Great minds think alike Rick whether QQQ July 65 puts, or continuation of the Great RE Monopoly Money Crash:

    While headlines gush over $275 B Twist until the end of the year, fact is the monetary base is going nowhere fast, down since Valentine’s Day, a deflationary market event to be sure:

    http://research.stlouisfed.org

    (View Data upper left corner)

    Valentine’s Day top in Bank Reserves also:

    http://research.stlouisfed.org

    And VD top in Securities held by Fed also:

    http://research.stlouisfed.org

    No wonder broad Money Velocity is the lowest on record:

    http://research.stlouisfed.org

    Meanwhile, cost of living Education, Food, Fuel, Medical Care, Rent and Utilities going up in double digits for the big consumer homeowner squeeze:

    http://research.stlouisfed.org

    http://research.stlouisfed.org

    http://research.stlouisfed.org

    http://research.stlouisfed.org

    Homes, the single largest asset of most Americans, continue to decline while fixed and adjustable mortgages compound and reset up:

    http://research.stlouisfed.org

    And the purchasing value of the consumer dollar continues to plummet:

    http://research.stlouisfed.org

    TTOBGH…