Nervous Bulls Energize Silver

Bullion quotes continue to ratchet higher, even as silver bulls (of all people!) warn that the rally has come too far, too fast. Ahh, there’s that old wall of worry  What could be more encouraging to long-term investors?  For it is only when silver’s most ardent supporters become cocksure, loading up aggressively for the next supposedly inevitable rally, that the trend will perhaps be in jeopardy – and then presumably only fleetingly.  For now, though, we need to remind ourselves that great bull markets are supposed to scare hell out of bulls and bears alike — just as this one has been doing since last autumn.  Check out the amazing spike in Silver’s weekly chart below.  While we wouldn’t attempt to argue that its parabolic pitch can be sustained indefinitely, we suspect that, no matter how ferocious the inevitable corrections yet to come,  they will look relatively innocuous years from now. For it is only at that point that we will be able to see them in the context of a long-term bull market that will have achieved heights as yet unimagined by most investors.

The chart may wind up looking much like one drawn today that shows the 1987 Crash. At the time, we thought the world was ending that Friday, October 16, as the Dow plummeted an unprecedented 108 points.  To the amazement of all, and the devastation of many, that proved to be just a warm-up for Monday, when a 508-point collapse brought the blue chip average down to 1739 – a 22% drop.  But look at the chart below and see if you can even find the ’87 crash.  While it is more than a blip, for sure, in the visual context of the spectacular bull market that was to follow, it looks like no more than the healthy, corrective pause it turned out to be.  If Silver futures were to get hit as hard in the weeks ahead, they’d find a bottom near $38. Hardly the end of the world.  Moreover, we suspect that, just like in 1987, it could produce the best buying opportunity we might see for years to come.

In the meantime, there don’t appear to be any developments in the real world that might derail the bull market in precious metals. Some technicians that we respect are calling for a sustained upturn in the dollar, but we can’t find any evidence of it in the charts.  And although, to be cautious, we routinely suspend our bearish skepticism whenever the Dollar Index hits an important new downside target as it did last week, we’ve yet to see a bounce with the kind of power it would take to end the dollar’s bear market.  Indeed, the most bullish event we could imagine for the U.S. dollar would be the collapse of Spain’s sovereign debt, and with it the euro. The dollar would most surely spike higher on the news, but the move would probably be short-lived, if for no other reason than that Spain’s all-but-inevitable collapse has already been discounted.  We could also see the dollar rising when Wall Street’s Mother of All Bear Rallies finally ends, as it conceivably could — any day. But the economic depression to follow would hardly be bullish for the dollar.  And while it might help bring down America’s trade deficit, it would also deliver a blow to tax revenues that would coax forth even more dollar-depreciating stimulus from the Federal Reserve.

Following Our Discipline

As a practical matter, the best we can do for now is monitor gold and silver prices very closely whenever they reach our proprietary rally targets.  Our current forecast leaves room for both to achieve at least somewhat higher highs before there’s reason for caution. (If you are not a subscriber but would like to access Rick’s Picks’ precise numbers and detailed trading instructions, click here for a free trial to the service. And if you want to learn more about our forecasting technique itself, click here.)  As always, if the price targets should be easily exceeded, that will allow us to stick confidently with the trend. It is only when the corrective selloffs overshoot their respective targets that we might raise a yellow flag.  So far, however, sellers have been unable to push either gold or silver beyond the midpoint of corrective patterns, and that is why we continue to urge subscribers to stay aboard.

(If you’d like to have Rick’s Picks commentary delivered free each day to your e-mail box, click here.)

  • Jess April 30, 2011, 3:36 pm

    Right on Rick! I don’t think this will end anytime soon too many see that any dips are buying opportunity, so to $38.00 is out in my opinion. Taking some off the table is always a good idea and I believe some see this as a time to take some profits. I also see that silver is making headlines at this price, when that happens the public begins to see they can get $33 for $1. 25 worth of coins and they are ready to “party on.” Brings more out for the shorts to get their hands on. This may happen for a short time but the smart will let their winners run! I can’t see it going below $46

  • Chris T. April 26, 2011, 4:00 am

    Rick:
    “…to follow would hardly be bullish for the dollar. And while it might help bring down America’s trade deficit,..”

    This is the simplest mechanism, and so easily believed, I certainly did.
    BUT, as Dr. Fekete only recently persuasively showed, nothing of the sort happens/happened:

    We played that same game, devalued the dollar against the exporters (Japan, etc), and what happened to the trade deficit over the last 30+ years?
    It exploded!

    I refer any and all interested to Dr. Fekete’s archive, he addressed this within the last 2 months or so.

  • Terry S April 26, 2011, 2:23 am

    No sell in May and go away… too much happen’!

  • Rich April 25, 2011, 7:32 pm

    Aloha All
    We just twittered we were stopped out of silver and into BAC and SPX. (INTC too)…

  • roger erickson April 25, 2011, 7:11 pm

    There should, in actuality, be no friction at all between operations & hoarding people. They all should just realize that the terms of the game were improved by going off the gold-std, to allow the game to scale up fantastically. Instead of hoarding commodities, there’s 100x more Group Output to be gained by sequestering coordination. Ask the DoD! Ask army ants vs snails! Ask any social species. Organization trumps commodity assets, every single time. That’s simply saying that strategy trumps tactics. It’s not rocket science.

    even Henry Morganthau himself didn’t even recognize the changed context of going off the gold std, i.e., that the formerly constraining, self-imposed real debt to gold-hoarding plutocrats was now only fiat debt, and needed an entirely different name!

    Fiat debt is meaningless. Our real debt is now in the form of a coordination disparity, as in banking lobbies vs the people. Our only defense is more coordination. They’re using Bernays strategies, and we can’t successfully resist by hoarding any amount of any commodity as a tactic.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jnYZVNVqBgU
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V0OrT-8gXMs

    the Morganthau quotes in this link, below, are truly educational – taken in context

    Impact of Fed Stimulus Debated
    http://econintersect.com/b2evolution/blog1.php/2011/04/24/impact-of-fed-stimulus-debated

    • Chris T. April 26, 2011, 3:56 am

      If you truly believe that, then you’re McClellan to their Clausewitz.

      You’re on the wrong battlefield fighting a phantom enemy (“formerly constraining, self-imposed real debt to gold-hoarding plutocrats “)..

      Your solution is the problem, nothing else.

  • Brad April 25, 2011, 6:55 pm

    Anyone got an opinion about the affect a default at the COMEX would have?

    My opinion is the short term silver bull last only as long as the shorts are forced to cover with physical silver.

    If we don’t continue to take delivery of silver to the point they are having to supplement what exist at COMEX….they can continue to sell short with the only consequence being they have to print more thin air money…..

    So, if Bernake’s speech doesn’t take the DOW & PMs down, the next option’s closure day/week May 20th, “should” unless COMEX is near defaulting on delivery.

    Sell in May and go away….why is this year different?

    • Rich April 25, 2011, 7:33 pm

      Cash settlement like some other futures…

  • BoozeMonkey April 25, 2011, 6:45 pm

    No doubt we can all expect some sleepless nights ahead as PMs scale the wall of worry : more and more people in the know are calling this as the mother of all bulls. Sounds like a wild ride…

  • Robert April 25, 2011, 6:26 pm

    Rick-

    Awesome post, and a great reminder that the great secular bull markets are designed to buck as many people as possible off the bull’s back…

  • Chris T. April 25, 2011, 5:51 pm

    BTW:
    notice how the DJ did nothing, by and large until the Fed got up and running about a decade or though after its creation?
    So much for the comment recently by one poster that one HAS TO expect the productivity growth of businesses to result in higher equity prices.

    It is the visual proof of the hard-money system at work, and proof of the speculation vs. investing comment from last week

    And, we can also see the marginal value of ever more credit declining to nothing in the end of the DJ parabola, ever more, for ever less effect

  • Chris T. April 25, 2011, 5:40 pm

    Rick,

    One thing always appreciated around here is that are willing to listen and think, as your “this just in” post shows.
    Not having seen the FOFOA comments, will have to take your word for it.

    I do recall you in the past though having foreseen a H-I at some point, just under different circumstances.
    I hope no one gloats and hula’s you, because those that do tend to be the ones that will NOT change their mind, no matter what.

    Finally, you point out the comment in the blog about $1500 being inexpensive.
    Recently, Marc Faber stated, that gold at $1500 now is cheaper that at $252 ten years ago…

    Then again, Jim Rogers recently said he would like a little cool down, so perhaps this morning’s takedown can start a bit of that.

  • A. Rand Fan April 25, 2011, 7:15 am

    Great article Rick. Thank you.
    An article posted last Thursday at lewrockwell.com (http://www.lewrockwell.com/orig10/galland25.1.html) was an interview with David Galland of Casey Research. He thinks The Bernanke will announce in his press conference this Wednesday the suspension of QE2 thereby causing the Market and commodities to fall in the short term. Could this be the trigger to take Silver back down to $38? BTW, 10:15 PM PST Silver $49.18

  • Rich April 25, 2011, 6:54 am

    China and Japan dumping the dollar fits Rick’s superbull silver scenario…

    • Cam Fitzgerald April 25, 2011, 2:01 pm

      Are they dumping the dollar though?

      When I consider China’s stated intention to reinvest up to two thirds of their treasure trove of US dollars into foreign investments, domestic social programs and resource purchases overseas I have to wonder if this is not in fact another way to keep commodity prices stable while potentially boosting the US economy and simultaneously rewarding China for such an approach.

      This action would provide something of an antidote to the end of Quantitative Easing, right?

      This might be left-field thinking here but we do not yet know where China might invest those dollars. Lets say it is the productive capacity of Europe and America though. What if the deployment of those reserves amounted to reinvestment in the slowing economies of the West? What if the so-called “dumping” of dollars actually created jobs? Good Lord, that sounds so unlikely, even impossible as most of us just assume that Asia is only looking out for itself and might happily see our economy ruined in the pursuit of their own self interests.

      I might have to sleep on this for a few more nights but it is worth considering that there could potentially be beneficial impacts. At the end of the day, it is not really in the interests of China or Japan to destroy the dollar, now is it.

      Put another way, if QE2 ceases or is not extended into QE3 and simultaneous to the end of US direct stimulus efforts we instead see hundreds of billions of dollars out of Asia redirected back into the global economy under Beijing’s authority…is that not then also another form of global stimulus but just in another guise?

      OK, now I can’t sleep. Where is my coffee?

    • Robert April 25, 2011, 6:16 pm

      Cam-

      I like you line of reasoning, but I can’t create the logical bridge between the positive “dollar re-investment in America” premise versus the negative “Inflationary dollar re-patriation” premise

      What I mean is- for the US Economy to resume growth (from a jobs perspective), the Chinese would have to come in and buy/start American BUSINESSES and staff them with American people.

      What the Chinese have mainly been doing around the world has been buying other countries’ ASSETS (real estate, natural resources, etc).

      When the Chinese do buy a business venture on foreign shores (as they have been doing in Africa and the Caribean) they typically import their OWN labor to staff the venture (since China has FAR more unemployed than the rest of the world).

      My suspicion is that when “the dollars come marching home” it won’t be with a “hurrah, hurrah”… it will be with a huge Chinese immigrant labor contingent, and when these worker come in with American dollars and start spending them in American stores, the results will be price increases that will not favor the average American worker (who will still be looking for the $75 dollar per hour factory jobs that are never coming back to this planet)

      Thoughts?

    • Rich April 25, 2011, 7:38 pm

      Insightful comments here on RA .
      Re China just looking out for itself, it did all along with mercantilist policies, military buildup and technology transfer aided and abetted by Bilderberg/CFR globalist policies.
      Re China investing in US like Japan, that could mean more cost push inflation here…

    • Cam Fitzgerald April 26, 2011, 3:34 am

      Thanks Robert, If you wan the truth, can’t really make the bridge either. I don’t think that post of mine made much sense in the end. It was pretty late and my mind was wandering. I was kind of just thinking out loud and processing while trying to find some good in what is really a bad situation and came up empty. Just one of those days when I could not make any connections of any use and probably should have just stayed in bed and kept sleeping.

    • mario cavolo April 26, 2011, 7:44 am

      Hi Gents,

      A couple of ideas came to my mind on this. First of all, its too early for China to be overly interested in investing in America. I had suggested in previous treatments that they will do so more and more, but only when the USD has fallen further than currently. There is now current substantial investment activity by Chinese in America, many picking up cheap real estate and investing in businesses to also gain the EB-5 investment visa status benefit. But it is still early in the game.

      The level of such China outbound private sector investment into the U.S. economy is rising but still relatively low. It will rise sharply as the dollar falls and it will further change the socio-economic landscape of America. Robert, as you noted, if they try to invest in America while also wanting to bring in their own cheap labor, that will be quite the battle.

      Secondly, it seems likely that they will deploy some of their reserves into U.S. equities as a hedge against the inflationary path we have all been put on. As the dollar falls, then U.S. stocks, commodities, etc. will rise. This scenario also suggest that China buying of U.S. equities will act as a continuing support of U.S. equity prices moving forward.

  • Terry S April 25, 2011, 4:54 am

    Good perspective on silver, Rick! Right on, JohnJay.

  • Robert April 25, 2011, 4:28 am
    • Cam Fitzgerald April 25, 2011, 6:24 am

      Thanks for that Robert. This whole “flation” debate can really make your head spin some days. That Fofoa article was pretty well done.

      By the time I was finished I was left asking myself “if the Powers that be were really resistant to inflating away debt then why has the dollar already lost virtually all it’s Gold-adjusted buying power over the past eight decades?”

      On the surface, the answer would seem to be self-evident as it was the preferred course of action as opposed to a deflation all along. It has indeed taken political will to achieve this which is exactly what we are agreed upon all along.

      What seems to matter most here is the speed with which the event takes place. A hyperinflation would be a rapid unexpected event.

      Perhaps all the arguments in favour of one extreme camp or another are moot as they really just point to a continued long slow devaluation towards worthlessness. A managed collapse that is…until another form of money supplants the offending paper and the debate just dies a natural death.
      ___________________________________
      Nice commentary today about Silver Rick. I liked the analogy of a correction being but a blip in the big picture. Makes perfect sense to me and I tend to agree with that idea. I am still expecting a correction though and am treating it as an inevitability. What goes straight up after all in an unrelenting way for months on end without facing a nasty sell-off eventually?

  • Robert April 25, 2011, 4:27 am

    Rick: It appears FOFOA wrote a piece specifically for you. Congratulations.

  • JohnJay April 25, 2011, 4:15 am

    With Bernanke locked into ZIRP with no way out, (unless Europe is conquered by Islam) anything is possible. Congress will never shut down half the Federal government and half the MIC, which would be a down payment on a new fiscal reality.
    The “long war” in AlPakIraq will go on and on, the troops will sit in Germany in case Hitler makes a comeback at 122 years of age. Ditto for England, Japan, etc.
    Thank god that France and the Phillipines kicked us out, otherwise we would still be there .
    Maybe when the Dollar becomes worthless enough, the rest of the world will finally kick our military out too!
    That will always be the dream anyway.